Caravan news
What's on guide
Caravan forum
Parks directory
Magazine subscriptions
Home page
Practical Motorhome
Practical Caravan
BUYING  HOLIDAYS  HELPLINE
ACCESSORY REVIEWBack to Product Test index
Reader Getaways

February 06: Generators

FULL INFORMATION, OVERVIEW AND COMPARISIONS CAN BE FOUND IN THE FEBRUARY 2006 ISSUE OF PRACTICAL CARAVAN MAGAZINE

WOLF 2300LR
Price £249
Tel 0500 414141
Web wwww.screwfix.com
Size 510 x 415 x 425mm
Weight 41.5kg
Fuel Tank Capacity 12 litres
Estimated Running Time (ERT) 10.6 hours
Continuous output 2000W
This open-frame device has a maximum output of 2200W, which allows for a 10% surge for appliances that require extra power on start up. For such a powerful unit it's surprisingly refined, and made little noise until we ran it at full power for a brief period.
The large 12-litre fuel tank keeps the unit running for up to 10.5 hours, and a fuel gauge in the tank's top shows you when it's time to top-up the fuel. Draining, filling and checking the oil is easy thanks to the sensibly positioned filler and drain plugs, and there's a low-oil warning light on the front panel.
The device is fitted with two domestic three-pin sockets, and there are two 12V screw terminals, should you choose to rig up battery-charging leads.
Verdict Wolf's largest offering is a high performing machine at a competitive price.
Rating * * * *

HONDA EU10I
Price £599.99
Tel 0800 028 4438
Web www.worldofpower.co.uk
Size 450 x 240 x 380mm
Weight 13kg
Tank capacity 2.3 litres
ERT 2.8 hours
Continuous output 900W
On paper, almost £600 for 900W doesn't seem like such a great bargain. But having said that, this machine is two or three generations ahead of its competitors. Its main innovation is the use of inverter technology that brings two major benefits to the user. First, the unit is much lighter. Second, the output is so finely regulated that you wouldn't have any qualms about running sensitive electronic equipment directly from the unit.
Honda has forged itself a reputation for being the producer of the some of the world's finest small petrol engines. After starting up this model, it's easy to see why. While the 87-decibel rating doesn't appear to be overly impressive, the actual sound generated is rather like that of a large expensive motorbike purring quietly away at idle. On the front panel, you'll find a three-pin domestic socket, as well as a 12V socket. There are plenty of warning lights to indicate when both oil and fuel levels are low.
Verdict An exceptionally refined device that's packed with features, although some caravanners might be put off by its high price.
Rating * * * * *
*** EDITOR'S CHOICE ***

WOLF 950
Price £79.99
Tel 0500 414141
Web wwww.screwfix.com
Size 370 x 310 x 360mm
Weight 22.5kg
Tank capacity 4.5 litres
ERT 5.8 hours
Continuous output 650W
As with most budget generators, this one has a two-stroke engine. We thought that this would result in lots of noise and blue smoke, but we couldn't have been more wrong. No more smoke was created than with the more expensive four-stroke machines, and while the running was less smooth, it wasn't any louder.
This is probably down to the suitcase-style casing, which acts as a noise shield.
But the main hassle with this unit, as with any two-stroke engine, is that you must mix in two-stroke oil with any new fuel you add. Fortunately, the 4.5-litre fuel tank allows the frugal little engine to run for up to 5.8 hours between refills, and the filler cap comes with a measuring jug to help you get the correct mix of oil and petrol.
There isn't a fuel gauge, which means that checking fuel levels entails removing the cap and peering into the tank. The front panel has a three-pin domestic mains socket, a 12V plug, and comes with battery charge leads.
Verdict Surprisingly refined given its two-stroke engine, but the lack of a fuel gauge is a nuisance.
Rating * * *

CLARKE G900
Price £281.94
Tel 01992 565300
Web www.clarkeinternational.com
Size 270 x 265 x 345mm
Weight 22.5kg
Tank capacity 1.5 litres
ERT 3.4 hours
Continuous output 600W
Clarke has tried to emulate the appearance of premium brand generators with this handy little suitcase unit, which is the smallest of all the models on test. At just over 22kg, few machines are lighter, which makes it well-suited to caravanners.
What's unusual for such a small unit is that it's powered by a refined four-stroke engine. On the downside, the Clarke's compact size means the fuel tank has a low 1.5-litre capacity. And despite the suitcase-style exterior, noise levels were comparable with those of the open-frame units in our test.
The 600W output isn't surprising given the unit's size, but this should have been reflected in a much lower price. The two 240V sockets are Continental in style, which means you'll have to buy an adapter before you can use them. Meanwhile, the single 12V socket is routed through two screw terminals.
Verdict This is a smart, compact unit, but it's not the easiest device to use in terms of connection.
Rating * * *

HONDA EC2200
Price £349.99
Tel 0800 028 4438
Web www.worldofpower.co.uk
Size 585 x 435 x 440mm
Weight 36kg
Tank capacity 3.6 litres
ERT 6 hours
Continuous output 1700W
Despite its open-frame design, this isn't as noisy a device as you might expect. A noise level of 97 decibels is quoted, yet the smooth engine note is more bearable than many supposedly quieter models.
A maximum power output of 2000W copes well with surge demands, while the powerful 1700W continuous running equates to a 7A mains hook-up supply.
Unlike most of the other units we tested, this machine doesn't have either a 12V or a domestic three-pin socket. Instead there are 110V and 230V round sockets. Your mains hook-up lead will plug directly into the blue 230V socket, but you must make sure your van's wiring is suitably fused to handle the maximum current produced.
Verdict If you need a big electrical output, and you don't want to spend a fortune, this open-frame unit is a good option - just be sure to check your wiring before use.
Rating * * *

HONDA EU30IS
Price £2279.99
Tel 0800 028 4438
Web www.worldofpower.co.uk
Size 655 x 480 x 570mm
Weight 61kg
Tank capacity 13 litres
ERT 16 hours
Continuous output 2800W
This is an astoundingly high price tag, even when you take the unit's superb performance into account. The only caravanners likely to consider buying a generator such as this are those who go touring for long periods of time and tend to use their van as a home-from-home. The maximum power output of 3000W allows for an extra 200W surge capacity, and the maximum continuous running output is an impressive 2800W.
Noise levels, although quoted at 91 decibels, don't seem noticeably louder than the smaller, editor's choice unit, and, again, the engine tone is similar to that of a large motorbike idling quietly. One very useful feature that is unique among the generators tested here is the electric start-up. On the front panel, there are two round 230V sockets, which are ideal for connecting your hook-up lead, plus a 12V socket. Amazingly, given the price, battery charger leads are not included.
Verdict The high price will rule this out for most caravanners, but it is an exceptionally powerful beast.
Rating * *

SIP MEDUSA T950
Price £94.98
Tel 01509 500300
Web www.sip-group.com
Size 366 x 308 x 376mm
Weight 20kg
Tank Capacity 4 litres
ERT 6.5 hours
Continuous output 750W
Coming in at under £100, the T950 is the baby of the SIP family, so you won't be surprised to learn that it comes with a two-stroke engine. Having said that, we were again surprised by the excellent performance that modern two-strokes offer. The unit sprang swiftly into life, and it generated very little noise.
Two-stroke engines are never as smooth as four-stroke engines, but here the sound level became disturbing only under continued maximum loading. The maximum continuous supply is roughly equal to that of a 3A electric hook-up, but the unit can supply up to 950W for short bursts to handle start-up surge demand.
Perhaps the best use for this little generator is as a leisure battery charger. SIP must think so too, since it supplies battery-charging leads to fit into the 12V output socket. There's also a domestic three-pin socket on the front panel.
Verdict Decent output, a low weight and a reasonable price make this a very useful device for caravanners.
Rating * * * *

SIP MEDUSA T1000
Price £154.99
Tel 01509 500300
Web www.sip-group.com
Size 440 x 340 x 380mm
Weight 25.5kg
Tank capacity 5.5 litres
ERT 8 hours
Continuous output 900W
This hybrid generator is essentially a budget suitcase-case style unit that boasts a four-stroke engine. But despite this, we actually found the engine to be less smooth than the two-stroke T950 model in the category beneath it. Under full load, the unit was very noisy, and when idling it continuously revved from slow to fast and back again.
Many generators do this from cold, but after warming up most run smoothly: not so with the T1000. This problem also affected power output. Under maximum load, our test unit stalled several times As usual, there are three-pin domestic and 12V sockets on the front panel. Battery charging leads are included too.
Verdict The poor running spoils what is otherwise a useful little generator with a pleasingly low weight and a good tank capacity.
Rating * * *

WOLF 1200
Price £139.96
Tel 0500 414141
Web wwww.screwfix.com
Size 450 x 350 x 370mm
Weight 29 kg
Tank capacity 6 litres
ERT 6 hours
Continuous output 1000W
For an open-frame generator, this one is reasonably compact and not especially heavy. The tank capacity is only six litres, but this gives six hours running time, which will be quite adequate for most caravanners' needs.
The 1000W output is equivalent to a 4.3A mains hook up, while a peak output of 1200W allows short bursts of extra power for start-up surge demand. It's also impressively quiet, with a maximum noise level of just 68 decibels. Even at full load, the tone was just a deep rumble.
From a usability point of view, this generator is excellent. It started easily, and immediately settled down to smooth running. The electricity generated can easily be used through either the three pin domestic main socket, or the 12V plug supplied. Battery charging leads are included, too.
Verdict Quiet, compact and easy to use, this is a great all-rounder.
Rating * * * * *
*** BUDGET CHOICE ***

SIP MEDUSA 2300
Price £299
Tel 01332 290833
Web www.carparts-direct.com
Size 510 x 415 x 425mm
Weight 41kg
Fuel Tank Capacity 12 litres
ERT 10.6 hours
Continuous output 2000W
This unit has a 2000W output equivalent to an 8.5A hook-up, and is meant to supply up to 2300W, if needed, on start-up. In practice, the generator tries to supply the power, but the engine can't keep up and stalls. This is a shame since it's otherwise a decent unit.
There are two domestic three-pin sockets on the front panel as well as a low-oil warning light. A full tank provides over 10 hours of fairly quiet running. We're surprised that at this price, there's neither a 12V socket nor battery charge leads.
Verdict A decent unit let down only by the unreliable surge power.
Rating * * *

NEXT MONTH: CAMP BEDS

Current month's review of some 'Great Gear' >>
HOME PAGE | TOP OF PAGE
BUYING  HOLIDAYS  HELPLINE
Contact Practical Caravan
Best viewed in screen resolution 800 x 600 using Internet Explorer or Firefox.